Please Read: Welcome to the new-look Inside the Gators
Inside the Gators staffers Jackson Colding, Andres Rodriguez, and Mark Wheeler take a closer look at Saturday’s match-up between No. 17 Florida and No. 3 Georgia, including which quarterback is more likely to lead the Gators to a win, what a win or loss would mean for Jon Sumrall, players to watch, and a score prediction.
What would a win against No. 3 Georgia mean for Jon Sumrall and the Florida Gators?
Colding: A win against No. 3 Georgia would mean a tremendous amount for this season and the big-picture outlook of the program. A win on Saturday would keep Florida in the middle of the College Football Playoff and SEC Championship Game conversation, and they would be one step closer to achieving those goals. If Florida is able to secure back-to-back wins over Texas and Georgia, this would prove they’re capable of winning the remaining games on their schedule. For the outlook of the program, beating Georgia in his first year would mean a lot for Sumrall. He has a chance to be the first Florida coach to beat Georgia in his first year since Jim McElwain, and starting his tenure against Georgia 1-0 would announce his arrival in the SEC. For a program that hasn’t beaten one of its biggest rivals in half a decade, a win on Saturday would show Sumrall has the ability to flip this rivalry back in Florida’s direction.
Rodriguez: This is the biggest game all season and one of the biggest games in a while for the Florida Gators. The path to make the SEC Championship is simple for the Gators: win out and it all starts right now against one of your biggest rivals who you have not beaten in six years. For Jon Sumrall to walk into Mercedes-Benz Stadium in year one and come out with a win against No. 3 Georgia would be massive. Not only would it give the Gators their third win against Top 10 opponents but it would set up a marquee matchup against another rival, Kentucky. Beating Georgia in a season where you have lost to South Carolina and No. 25 Missouri sounds unprecedented but it’s a victory like one against the Bulldogs that broadens the picture moving forward. Florida has been close in the last few years; in 2024 DJ Lagway went down with an injury while Florida was up and in 2025 a controversial call ruined the Gators’ chance of winning. If there is any year to beat Georgia, it’s 2026 and Sumrall knows that.
Wheeler: The mounting criticism Jon Sumrall was receiving on social media (which isn’t necessarily a reflection of how the Gator Nation feels) receded with the road win over Texas. A loss here isn’t going to really hurt Sumrall’s perception among Florida fans because Georgia is seen as the better overall program at this time. However, a win, in his first game ever as the head coach against the hated Bulldogs, would basically give him a season or two worth of a free pass among the fan base. So yes, a loss is all but expected, but a win would be HUGE! As for the team, a win helps keep momentum on their side and maybe even makes them a favorite to make the 12-team CFB Playoffs. A loss, on the other hand, all but eliminates them. I doubt a team with two blowout losses to so-so teams is a serious contender if they suffer a third loss.
Jon Sumrall stated that he won’t publicly announce a starting quarterback, but do you believe Aaron Philo or Tramell Jones Jr. would be more likely lead UF to a win?
Colding: If both quarterbacks are healthy, junior quarterback Aaron Philo is more likely to lead UF to a win against Georgia. While sophomore quarterback Tramell Jones Jr. led Florida to a win over Texas, he threw for 155 yards on 22 completions. His longest completion was 17 yards to sophomore wide receiver Dallas Wilson, and not a lot of his passes went beyond the first down marker. Coach Jon Sumrall said Monday on his Gator Talk show that the number of motions or shifts the offense can do changes with Jones Jr. in the game. Also, he said there have to be more plays on the wristband than a coach to player communication. While Philo also hasn’t thrown the ball down the field much, his deeper understanding of the offense provides Florida with a more likely path to win this game. Against Georgia’s defense, Florida’s offense will have to execute at a high level, and Philo is more likely to execute at a higher level with his understanding of the offense.
Rodriguez: This is a tricky question to answer because I believe both QB’s can lead Florida to a victory against Georgia. However, I think Tramell Jones Jr. puts the Gators at a bigger advantage. Jones has the arm talent but not the accuracy yet but the one thing I want to focus on is his ability to run. Philo has proved he can run, but not at the level Jones showed against Texas. In a game against the 12th best defense in the country, that front seven is going to get pressure on the quarterback and when that pocket collapses, I would rather have the sophomore. Jones ran for 41 yards against the Longhorns but it was his ability to shift in the pocket and get away from danger that allowed the Gators to get their first win at Texas in program history, and I believe if he is named QB1 for this rivalry, the Gators can pull it off.
Wheeler: Because Florida lost the last two games that Aaron Philo started and won the game Tramell Jones Jr. started, there’s a certain segment of the fanbase who are vocal about their support for Jones Jr. However, as is often the case at every level of football, quarterbacks receive an unfair amount of criticism after a loss, and at times, an unwarranted amount of credit for a win. I believe that is the case here. Jones Jr. definitely played better than I expected overall, mostly because he didn’t turn the ball over, but outside of the fourth down completition to Dallas Wilson, he didn’t have much of an impact throwing the ball. Despite having a better arm, he seemed to be a day late and a dollar short on most of his throws down the field. For the day, he was 8-of-8 for 37 yards on passes behind the line of scrimmage, but only 5-of-12 for 58 yards on pass attempts beyond 10 yards. He simply wasn’t able to take advantage of having a bigger arm. Though he has a weaker arm, Philo has seen more success in the limited attempts he has had downfield. That, along with his comfort level with the offense, should give Philo the nod.
Other than the quarterbacks, who are the key players to watch for?
Colding: The key players to watch for Florida are junior running back Jadan Baugh and junior linebacker Myles Graham. Baugh was able rush for 91 yards and a touchdown against Texas and make an impact. Despite averaging under four yards a carry, he was still able to make an impact in the game by wearing down the Texas defense. In a homecoming game for him in Atlanta, Florida will need Baugh to continue to elevate his play close to where he was in the beginning of the season to open up the passing attack. His ability to wear down Georgia’s defense will be influential in Florida’s ability to win the game. Graham is one of the leaders of the defense, and he made a substantial impact in Florida’s win over Texas. He had the strip sack to help clinch Florida’s victory, and he will need to make more impact plays for Florida to have a chance at beating Georgia for the first time in five years. He is one of the leaders of Florida’s defense, and he will be one of the players Florida looks to when they need a play to be made. He has three sacks in the last two games, so his ability to get pressure on Georgia fifth-year quarterback Gunner Stockton will be key toward the success of Florida’s defense. The key players for Georgia are Stockton and senior linebacker Raylen Wilson. The key for Stockton is to not turn the ball over, as he had three turnovers against Auburn. He has thrown for 1,570 yards and 16 touchdowns, while throwing four interceptions. If Stockton is able to take care of the ball, then he will make it hard for Florida to beat them. Wilson leads Georgia in tackles and sacks, with 43 total tackles and four sacks. If he is able to get pressure on either one of Florida’s quarterbacks, then Florida will have a hard time moving the ball on Georgia’s defense. His ability to create problems for Florida’s offensive line is key for Georgia to win this game.
Rodriguez: Jadan Baugh. If Florida wants to win this game, Baugh needs to be an integral part of this offense. South Carolina and Missouri did a good job of shutting Baugh down, and when he is not present, this team is not present. It won’t be easy for Baugh, Georgia’s defense will stack the box and prevent him from getting loose but he has a chip on his shoulder. He wants to prove he is still that guy he was in the first four games of the season and he did that against Texas, rushing for 91 yards. I said it last week, and I’ll say it again; Vernell Brown III is this offense’s biggest piece. Without him on the field, that spark has not been the same and with him being listed as probable this week, it seems like we will see him for the first time since Ole Miss. Buster Faulkner said this week that he turns five-yard plays into 20+ yard plays and in a game where I think it’ll be extremely close, those extra yards are the difference between a heartbreaking loss or a season-defining win.
Wheeler: While Florida has one of the better linebacking corps in the SEC, the No. 1 overall unit resides in Athens, Georgia, where Raylen Wilson and Chris Cole are pos- season candidates to be selected to however many All American teams there are out there nowadays. How Jadan Baugh performs against them will likely be the tell tale sign as to whether Florida’s offense is made to be one dimensional on Saturday.
Prediction
Colding: Despite a bounce-back win over Texas, Florida is going to drop its sixth straight game and ninth of its last 10 against the Georgia Bulldogs. Even though Florida’s offense was able to have some success against Texas in the previous game, they will have an even taller task in trying to find success against Georgia’s defense. The defense showed improvement against Texas, but Georgia’s offense will be able to have success on Florida’s defense following their loss to Auburn. Georgia hasn’t lost back-to-back games in the regular season since coach Kirby Smart’s first season in 2016, and they will continue that streak on Saturday. Even though Florida was able to overcome adversity against Texas, Smart’s teams have an extended track record of being mentally tough and able to overcome any adversity they face. Georgia 34-24
Rodriguez: I have never been happier to be wrong; I chose Texas thinking the Gators would get blown out of the water, but as you can tell my picks have not been the best lately. My 4-0 start will be remembered for generations. For the last two weeks I have been arguing with myself, thinking who to choose in this game. Georgia is out looking for blood after losing to Auburn and Florida is riding an extreme high and have nothing but everything to lose at the same time. It’s Halloween; anything can happen and the good thing for Florida is that history is on its side. The Gators are 4-1 against the Bulldogs on Halloween and I think they make it 5-1. For the first time since 2020, Florida takes the World’s Largest Outdoor Cocktail Party. Florida 38-35
Wheeler: Not only has Georgia risen to the ranks of being a National power under Kirby Smart, but they have dominated Florida to the tune of an 8-2 record during his tenure. With this being a new regime in Gainesville, how much of the past do we throw out the window, and how much is relevant to how well Smart has performed against UF? To me, the two biggest question marks are who starts at quarterback for Florida, and do we see the Georgia or the one that gave up over 100 yards rushing to Byrum Brown last week? Jones Jr. is more likely to take advantage of that than Philo. Either way, this will come down to whether Florida’s defense plays like they did last week or the previous several weeks. Georgia 31-17
Season-to-date Predictions
| Game | Jackson (3-4) | Andres (4-3) | Mark (2-5) |
| FAU | W | W | W |
| Campbell | W | W | W |
| Auburn | L | W | L |
| Ole Miss | W | W | L |
| Missouri | L | L | L |
| South Carolina | L | L | L |
| Texas | L | L | L |