Take Five: 2025 Florida Football Preview

by Mark Wheeler
2 comments

Please Read: Welcome to the new-look Inside the Gators

Florida’s first game of the 2025 season is a mere 30 hours away. Before No. 15 Florida kicks off against Long Island, Inside the Gators offers up this Take Five Fall 2025 Season Preview.

Five Newcomers to Keep an Eye on

  • Brendan Bett: After contributing as a freshman, he sat out last season at Baylor because of academics. How much will that set him back? Florida needs him to be able to hit the ground running this season. We’re going to be watching to see if that happens.
  • Ty Jackson: He doesn’t have great size, but he is incredibly physical for his size and moves really well. He isn’t in the two deep to start the season, but he will be a player to watch for in spot duty and on special teams.
  • Joseph Mbatchou: As new as he is to football (he only played one season of American high school football), it’s hard to imagine him coming in and making an impact as a true freshman in the SEC. However, he has size and natural strength, and quickness to make some plays. Add in the fact that UF is unsettled at defensive tackle, and we could see him get more snaps than you might have otherwise imagined.
  • J. Michael Sturdivant: His transfer from UCLA seems like the most natural of fits. His forte is catching the deep ball, while DJ Lagway excels at throwing the deep ball. I see some big plays in his immediate future. Plus, he looks like the grown-up in the room compared to the other receivers.
  • Vernell Brown III: This should be a familiar name to the Gator Nation at this point, not just because his father played for and worked for Florida football, but because of how often he was mentioned by coaches and players over the spring and fall. He has more acceleration and ‘make you miss’ than outright track speed, but that’s something UF is lacking and a niche he can fill.

Five Sink or Swim

  • TJ Abrams: His terrible spring game outing led me to believe that he might hit the Transfer Portal in the offseason. He didn’t. However, we’ve heard all four of the true freshmen receivers receive praise from the coaches and other players, but I don’t remember a single word about Abrams. If he falls behind the freshmen, that’s the writing on the wall.
  • Devon Manuel: After transferring in from Arkansas, Manuel was slated to be the top backup at left tackle last season. An injury prevented that from happening. Then he was arrested in the offseason, and the last I saw of him in fall camp, he was off working by himself on the side.
  • Kamryn Waites: Florida has tried him out at both guard and tackle, but he hasn’t been able to find a place to shine – or even be a solid contributor. Last offseason, he looked to be in much better shape than he was in 2022 or 2023, but that hasn’t carried over to him being an SEC-caliber lineman to this point.
  • Treyaun Webb: After contributing as a true freshman, it looked like he was going to be in the position to be the third back last year, but he was limited to four games by an injury. His chance to solidify himself as the third back this offseason was untracked by yet another injury. He is likely be be buried on the depth chart before he gets a chance to get back on the field.
  • Bryce Thornton: Don’t get me wrong, Thornton started to come on last year. Having said that, he has physical limitations that Lagonza Hayward and Drake Stubbs don’t have. If he slips up at all, they look ready to pounce.

Five Potential Surprises

  • Tarvorise Brown: How far has he come? Last fall, coaches were stopping practice to help him get in a proper stance and with his foot placement. He looks much more technically sound this offseason. He made our First Five off the Bus feature back in the spring, and he looked even better this fall. UF needs some defensive tackles to step up. He is a candidate to do that.
  • Tank Hawkins: Because he has speed to spare, I thought he would have been more involved last year than he actually was. Now, with departures and players being limited by injury, he is actually one of the more experienced receivers. He needs to get off to a fast start in these first two games to show he can be counted on in SEC play. If that happens, I like his chances to break a couple of long ones this season.
  • Amir Jackson: I’m not 100% sure on this one. We didn’t get to see much in the way of practice over the spring or fall, so I am basing this partially on Billy Napier commenting on him last week as being a player who has stepped up in practice. Florida plays so damn much 12 personnel that it only makes sense if at least one of the tight ends is a receiving threat. If not, put another receiver out there. After a forgettable true freshman season, could it be Jackson’s time to shine?
  • Byron Louis: A consistent during fall camp was his ability to break off a big play. UF has some backfield talent, but they don’t have anyone who is a consistent threat to take it to the house. Louis could be that guy.
  • Drake Stubbs: After a strong spring, he suffered some setbacks in fall camp, but he has the potential to take a starting safety job if either of the starters falters. He has size, physicality, and ball skills. All he needs is experience.

Five Potential Disappointments

  • Caleb Banks: I am 100% sold on his potential, but not on his actual production. As we’ve seen, when he brings his A game, he has a chance to be a difference maker. The problem is that, as we have seen in games and when coaches and fellow players have called him out in practices, he doesn’t always go hard. If he plays this season like it is a contract season (which it is in a sense, considering it will impact where he is drafted) he has a chance to have a big season.
  • Hayden Hansen: His 15 catches in 13 starts last year earned him a place on the Preseason Mackey Award Watch List. It’s either a down year at the position, or they are expecting more out of him than he has been able to deliver to this point in his three-year Florida career. He absolutely looks the part, by all accounts, he is a great teammate and a leader, but his production isn’t that of an SEC starter at the position (but that can be said of the entire tight end room). I don’t know why anyone would think that is going to change this year.
  • The Offensive Line: They’ve gotten so much offseason hype, and there’s something to be said about bringing back four of five starters, but I’m not completely sold on them. These high rankings and grades are based primarily on the low number of sacks they gave up last year. But should they be? The unit protected two kinds of quarterbacks last season. Graham Mertz and his 10-yard passing attack got the ball out quickly, which would naturally keep down sack numbers. And then, they blocked for a unicorn in DJ Lagway, who would absorb hits and potential sacks and keep on playing. Being honest with yourself, how many times did he brush off would-be sacks in just the last two or three regular-season games? He avoided at least five, six, or seven would be, should have been, sacks to make plays with defenders bouncing off him or draped over him. That isn’t a credit to the line, that’s a credit to his genetics.
  • Aidan Warner: It isn’t easy to label a past walk-on as a disappointment, but the staff could be setting him up to be one. After a disastrous 2024 season, maybe you write that off as him being in over his head when called upon in an emergency. However, he looked bad in the spring game and didn’t exactly shine in the one entire practice we (the media) were able to watch (but not speak about). If he really is the better bet over Harrison Bailey – UF has missed the boat bringing in another Transfer Portal quarterback.
  • Dallas Wilson: He is currently sidelined, but as he showed over the spring, he has the potential to be a great one. However, there’s still two issues. The first being, never put a great deal of stock in what a receiver does in the spring. The second is that Florida fans are envisioning a Jeremiah Smith type of true freshmen season – and while he may have a good season, expecting something that spectacular (76-catches, 1,315-yards, and 15 touchdowns) is likely going to end up in setting up many in the Gator Nation for a major disappointment.

Five Reasons to be Optimistic

  • Confidence: Call it confidence, momentum, or whatever you like, but when things are going well, you expect them to go well, and that plays a part in the outcome, just like when things aren’t going well and you’re basically waiting for the other shoe to fall, for something bad to happen. As James Bates told us in a feature a few years ago, those Steve Spurrier teams had swagger. They went into the games expecting to win. It feels like this year’s version of Florida football has the same outlook to a degree.
  • Continuity: In the Transfer Portal Era, when players are free to roam from program to program from year to year, it’s challenging to find a team returning at least somewhat intact. Now, UF isn’t at that level, but returning 13 starters and quite a few productive backups from an eight-win season, in most cases, should equal an improved record (if they remain healthy). If you go starter by starter, only one player (J. Michael Sturdivant) wasn’t with the team last year. Everyone else knows the player beside him, knows his strengths, weaknesses, and tendencies. They know the game week and game day routine. That part is down pat, leaving only what happens on the field to think about. That has to count for something.
  • DJ Lagway: Though the sample size is incredibly limited, Lagway has proven to be a unicorn of sorts. He might have the most arm talent of any Florida quarterback this side of Rex Grossman. If sitting out all live action drills over the spring and 95% in the fall hasn’t set him back significantly, there is every reason to believe that he has a chance to make enough plays each game to put Florida in a good enough position to win week in and week out.
  • Surge in Talent: Position by position, overall, Florida is more talented this year than they were last year when they won eight games, including the last four in a row. There are some concerns at backup quarterback, defensive tackle, and depth in the secondary, but overall, this is an incredibly talented bunch.
  • Speed: If it wasn’t already well known, go back to the statistics provided by Urban Meyer during his stay in Gainesville, and overwhelmingly, an offense’s scoring percentage increases in drives with an explosive play. You aren’t going to continuously go on 10-12 play scoring drives. There are too many opportunities to make a mistake, such as an untimely penalty to put you behind the sticks or a turnover. Speed kills in football. Florida isn’t quite back to the Meyer days, but they do feature more speed than they have in the last decade.

Five Reasons to be Pessimistic

  • Billy Napier: Has Florida turned a corner under Billy Napier? I don’t know. Neither do you. What I do know is that there is a three-year, 38-game, sample size that screams he hasn’t shown to be average, much less a top-tier head coach. Whether it be his record against FBS opponents (14-19), ranked opponents (4-14), traditional rivals (3-10), SEC opponents (10-14), and SEC opponents away from home (4-10) – there’s nothing anyone can point to in order to defend his stay in Gainesville. The bottom line is, the biggest question mark about Florida football is having Napier on the sidelines each Saturday.
  • DJ Lagway: As I stated above, he is a unicorn. He has a knack for turning would-be negative plays into first downs and hits the deep ball better than anyone in college football. Those two things in themselves give UF a fighting chance to be a playoff-caliber team. There are some issues, though, as well, starting with his injury history, followed closely by his lapses in reading defenses in the short and intermediate passing game. That is understandable for a true freshman, and you would almost think it a given that he has improved in those areas, except that he has been limited all offseason and hasn’t had much live-action drills practice time until the last 10 or so days of fall camp.
  • Thin Secondary: According to Billy Napier, Florida has what it considers three starters at cornerback. All are talented, but unfortunately, two of the three have an injury history that should cause some sleepless nights among the coaches. Devin Moore has played in only 19 of his possible 38 career games. Cormani McClain only played in three of a possible 13 games for UF last year. If one or both of them continue along that path, it’s going to spell trouble. That doesn’t even take into account a thin safety position. The only secondary spot that seems solid is Star, and that could lead to Aaron Gates playing some corner if there are injuries over there.
  • Unproven Receiver Unit: Florida’s wide receiver room is long on talent and potential, but short on actual production. UF has but three receivers with more than 20 career college catches – J. Michael Sturdivant, Eugene Wilson III, and Kahleil Jackson – and two of the three – Wilson III and Jackson – are battling injuries. There is some young, unproven talent, but to think that three or four of them are going to have breakout type of years is akin to hoping to draw an inside straight. Could it happen? Yes. Is it likely? No.
  • Interior Defensive Line: As the old Wendy’s commercial used to ask – Where’s the Beef? Don’t get me wrong, there are some big bodies along the interior defensive line, and the staff swears they like their numbers, but much like with the receiver group, they may be long on talent, but they are short on production, with quite a few questions that need to be answered. UF needs at least two or three players who weren’t regular contributors last year to be capable contributors this year. One solution might be to have Tyreak Sapp take more snaps inside.

Go to discussion...

Related Articles

2 comments

  1. Good article Mark. It covers all of the possibilities. I think Bailey might be the find of the year if Lagway goes down. I am a little concerned about the depth of the D-line and also worry that the O-line has been overhyped because of the way Lagway avoids sacks. After watching USF get after it on Defense against Boise State, we will find out about the O-line next week. Go Gators.

Leave a comment

Please log in to your forum account to comment

Community platform by XenForo® © 2010-2022 XenForo Ltd. | Style and add-ons by ThemeHouse